2007-091 TOVN OF QUEENSBURY
742 Bay Road,Queensbury,NY 12804-5902 (518)761-8201
Community Development- Building &Codes (518) 761-8256
CERTIFICATE (-)NUE7 OCCUPANCY
Permit Number. P20070091 Date Issued: Friday, May 25, 2007
This is to certify that work requested to be done as shown by Permit Number P20070091
has been completed.
Tax Map Number. 523400-252-000-0001-075-004-0000
Location: 2999 STATE ROUTE 9L
Owner. CAPITAL REGION PROPERTIES, LLC
Applicant: CAPITAL REGION PROPERTIES, LLC
This structure may be occupied as a:
Commercial Alteration
By Omer of Town Board
TOWN OF QUEENSBURY
Issuance of this Certificate of Occupancy DOES NOT relieve the
property owner of the responsibility for compliance with Site Plan,
Variance, or other issues and conditions as a result of approvals by the
Planning Board or Zoning Board of Appeals. Drrectorof Building&Code Enforcement
1 UWN OF QUEENSBURY
742 BaylLoad, Queensbury, Ny 12804-5902 (S18) 761-8201
Community Development -Building & Codes (518) 761-8256
BUILDING PERMIT
Permit Number: P20070091 Application Number.
~ I A20070091 tv
Tax Map No: 523400-252-000-0001-075-~4-0000 N
N
Permission is herebygranted to: CAPITAL REGION PROPERTIES, LLC
Forpropertylocated at: 2999 STATE ROUTE 9L J
in the Town of b Ul
Queens ury, to construct or place -
at the above location in accon3ance with application together with plot plans and other information hereto filed
and approved and in compliance with the NYS Uniform Building Codes and the Queensbury Zoning
Ordinance.
Owner Address: CAPITAL REGION PROPERTIES, L Twe of Construction Value
1754 CENTERAL Ave Commercial Alteration $3,000.00
ALBANY, NY 12205-0000 Total Value ~ $3,000.00
Contractor or Builder's Name /Address
Electrical Inspection Agency
PAUL GENTNER
14 NOAH Dr
QUEENSBURY, NY 12804-0000
Plans & Specifications
2007-091
CABIN #5 DUNHAM'S BAY RESORT: 1296 sq ft commercial alteration conversion of two hotel units
one
$155.52 PERMIT FEE PAID -THIS PERMIT EXPIRES: Thursday, May 15, 2008
(If a longer period is required, an application for an extension must be made to the code Enfon:emern Officer
of the Town of Queensbury before the expiration date.)
Dated at the Town ensbur~ Tuesday, May 15, 2007
SIGNED BY ~" fir`" ~ `~ `~
-_---~ for the Town of Queensbury
>o-_ h _
_ Director of Building &~~
)orcement
TOWN OF QUEENSBURY
742 Bay Road, Queensbury, NY 12804-5902 (518) 761-8201
Community Development -Building & Codes (518) 761-8256
BUILDING PERMIT
Permit Number: P20070091
Application Number. A20070091
Tax Map No: 523400-252-000-0001-075-004-0000
Permission is herebygranted to: CAPITAL REGION PROPERTIES, LLC
For property located at:
2999 STATE ROUTE 9L
in the Town of Queensbury, to construct or place
at the above location in accordance with application together with plot plans and other information hereto filed
and approved and in compliance with the NYS Uniform Building Codes and the QueensburyZoning
Ordinance. Type of Construction Value
C+wner Address: CAPITAL REGION PROPERTIES, L
1754 CENTERAL Ave Commercial Alteration $3,000.00
ALBANY, NY 12205-0000 Total Vatue $3,000.00
Contractor or Builder's Name /Address
PAUL GENTNER
14 NOAH Dr
QUEENSBURY, NY 12804-0000
Electrical Inspection Agency
Plans & Specifications
-091
#5 DUNHAM'S BAY RESORT: 1296 sq ft commercial alteration conversion of two hotel units
gone
X155.52 1'EKNltT FEE PAID -THIS PERMIT EXPIRES:
(If a longer period is required, an application for an extension must be made to the code Enforcement Officer
of the Town of Queensbury before the expiration date.)
Dated at the To eensb 'I t}esc~ay, May 15, 2007
SIGNED BY «~:{ ~-, ` ` `~~
~' < for the Town of Queensbury.
~, ; .:
Director of Building SL'°~ode orcement
Thursday, May 15, 2008
~-,-i L... -'._ / ••-OFFICE USE ---------------•---- -- _
' ` t ^[y/ ONLY ~ --------------
~ ~ r r .~
TAX MAP NO. ~ `~ ~~G? f r ,
PERMIT NO: Y ll ( ; r
~~
FEES: PERMIT ECREATION ' % '
____-__-__,_ENGINEERLNG ' r "~ '
r r .!~.~
r '
(If applicable)
------------- r
------------------------------------' r--.-.
PRINCIPAL STRUCTURE:
APPLICATION FOR ZONING APPROVAL ~ BUILDING
PERMIT
A PERMIT MUST BE OBTAINED BEFORE BEGINNING CONSTRUCTION. APPLICATION IS SUBJECT TO
REVIEW BEFORE ISSUANCE OF A VALID PERMIT FOR CONSTRUCTION.
APPLICANT/BUILDER: ~G, V 1 G e non ec
ADDRESS: ~ 4 Nc~,.l~, ~V Q A~Qr-u r~,rk N ~,
1201
PHONE NOS. .J 7 ~j - $ $ 3 g
OWNER: 1~ ~G+n ~~c~S'~Qih
ADDRESS: ?b• ~o X gy ~; Gceanb~s(n N Y.
f ZO(n {
PHONE NOS. $'7'j-$g3~j
CONTACT PERSON FOR BUILDING & CODES COMPLIANCE:~owt Gen~net PHONE: 57 7- 8838
LOCATION OF PROPER TY:. 29~ q
` ~~ q ~
( ~,Q /tQ ~'e o~ e N ~ ~ 2gyS
SUBDIVISION NAME:
PLEASE I NDICATE MEA SUREMENTS AS REQUIRED BELOW:
CHECK ALL THAT z
APPLY TO YOUR z ~ ~ ~ Cj p ~
PROJECT O
H O
~~ O
O
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
W
i=
~
Z v
° ~
a ° Q a
wz
a - N° o~ oLL ~
.
a=~
SINGLE FAMILY
TWO-FAMILY
MULTI-FAMILY
(NO, of UNITS )
TOWNHOUSE
BUSINESS OFFICE
RETAIL-
MERCANTILE
FACTORY OR
INDUSTRIAL
ATTACHED
GARAGE(1,2,3)
OTHER I"1o~ Q.~ V ! ~Q (.p ~+
IF COMMERCIAL OR IND USTRI AL- NAME OF BUSINFS S• lJunY~ [l.nn'c ~_ _. ~,..._.~.
ARE THERE STRUCTURES NOT SHOWN ON PLOT PLAN? 1~1 ~
ARE THERE EASEMENTS ON PROPERTY? ~2S .
I acknowledge no construction activities shall be commenced prior to issuance of a valid
permit. I certify that. the ,application, plans, and supporting.materials are a true and
complete statement/description of the work proposed, that all work will be performed in
accordance with the NY State Building Codes, local building laws and ordinances, and in
conformance, with local zoning regulations. I acknowledge that prior to occupying the
facilities proposed, I or my agents will obtain a certificate of occupancy. I also understand
that I/we are required to provide an as-built survey by a licensed :land surveyor of all newly
constructed facilities prior to issuance of a certificate of occupancy.
I have read d agree to the above.
Signed
Director of Building & Codes 761-8256 (for questions regarding Building Permits, construction
codes or septic systems)
Zoning Administrator: 761-8218 (for questions regarding required permits, the permit process,
application requirements or to schedule an appointment)
:Permission is hereby granted to the above
Applicant to erect or after the building ;
described herein in accordance with said
; Application:
~ 1' ' a. l i` ' ~ ;
BUILDI G CODES ROVAL ;
,,.~ ,
DAT
f This application /proposed action described
herein is found to be in accordance with the ;
zoning Laws of the Town of Queensbury.
ZONING APPROVAL
DATE. ;
Multiple Dwelling, Hotel, Motel, Apartment
Final Inspection Report
Office No.: (518) 761-8256 Date Ins ection requ rec ' ed:
Queensbury Building & Code Enforcement Arrive: ~ part; am/
742 Bay Ro~a-d~,,Queensbury, NY 12804 Inspector's Inih
NAME: ~\ ~) ~~F-~Qt~~~__`1` PE #: °- ~ I
LOCATION t1 \ L~~ 1~1~ ~ DA - ~ ~--,~ ?
COMMENTS:
Y N NA
Chimne Hei t / "B" Vent /Direct Vent Location
Plumb Vent Thru Roof Minimum 6"
Roof Com lete
Exterior Finish Com lete /Finish Grade 6" In 10' Dro
Interior/Exterior Railings 34 Into 38 in. / 36" Landing, Decks,
Porches
Exterior Handrails, Balconies, Landin 30" Or More
Interior Handrails Balconies / Landin 30" Or More
Interior Handrails Stairs 1 or More Risers
Guardrails 42", Ballisters 4" Minimum S acin
Vestibules For Exit Doors > 3000 . ft.
Doors 36" /Lever Handles
Headroom 6' 8" on Stairs
Bathroom /Kitchen Waterti ht
Smoke Detectors: Every level, Every bedroom
Outside eve bedroom, Interconnected Batte Backu
Bathroom Fans / Plumbin Fixtures Com lete
Foundation Insulation
Fire S aration, %, 1, 2 hr.
Fire Walls 1, 2, 3 Hour /Fire Door'/., 1 '~4, 2 Hour
Handica Accessibilit / Handica ed Parkin Si na e
Gas Lo In Sealed or Glass Enclosure
Gas Valve Shut-Off Ex sed / Re ator 18" Above Grade
Gas Furnace Shut-Off Within 30 ft. or Within Line Site
Oil Furnace Shut t Entrance to Furnace Area
Furnace eater O ratin Fresh Air Intake
Low Water Shut-Off for Boiler
elief Valve eat Tra /Water tem 110 De rees Max.
arc a ire roofin Com fete, Penetration Sealed
Furnace In S crate Room /Protected Gars e
Li t Ventilation r Room /Safe Glazin
Attic Access 30" x 20" x 30" H / Crawl S ace 18" x 24"
Final Electrical
Site Plan/Variance R aired
Final Surve Plot Plan /Flood Plain Certification, if Re .
As-built Se tic S stem Layout Re aired
Buildin / A artment Number on Buildin or Drivewa
Build Access All Sides by 20', Driv ace 20" Wide
Oka To Issue Tem C/O ermanent CO ci le one]
Okay To Issue C/C
Last printed 11/ 17/2003 9:13 AML:\PamW\Building h Codes\Inapectioa Forms\MULTIPLE DWELLING.doc
S/2 3
Multiple Dwelling, Hotel, Motel, Apartment
Final Inspection Report
Office No.: (518) 761-8256 Date Inspection re st r eiv
Queensbury Building & Code Enforcement Arrive:~~. a / m Depart: ~ am/~~.
742 Bay Road, Queensbury, NY 12804 Inspector's Inliials:
NAME: PERMIT # : ~~
LOCATION: ~,1 ~ L~~tJ -7- ~~ DATE: ,~Z3~'D7
Y N NA
Chimne Hei ht / "B" Vent /Direct Vent Location
Plumb Vent Thru Roof Minimum 6"
Roof Com lete
Exterior Finish Com lete /Finish Grade 6" In 10' Dro
Interior/Exterior Railings 34 Into 38 in. / 36" Landing,
Decks, Porches
Exterior Handrails, Balconies, Landin 30" Or More
Interior Handrails Balconies /Landin 30" Or More
Interior Handrails Stairs 1 or More Risers
Guardrails 42", Balusters 4" Minimum S acin
Vestibules For Exit Doors > 3000 s . ff.
Doors 36" /Lever Handles
Headroom 6' 8" on Stairs
Bathroom /Kitchen Waterti ht
Smoke Detectors: Every level, Every bedroom
Outside every bedroom, Interconnected Battery
Backu
Carbon Monoxide Alarm - lowest slee in level
Bathroom Fans / Plumbin Fixtures Com late
Foundation Insulation
Fire Se aration, 3/a, 1, 2 hr.
Fire Walls 1, 2, 3 Hour /Fire Door ~/a, 1 ~/~, 2 Hour
Handicapped Accessibility /Handicapped
Parkin /Si na e
Gas Lo In Sealed or Glass Enclosure
Gas Valve Shut-Off Exposed /Regulator 18" Above
Grade
Gas Furnace Shut-Off Within 30 ff. or Within Line Site
Oil Furnace Shut-Off at Entrance to Furnace Area
Furnace /Hot Water Heater O eratin /Fresh Air Intake
Low Wa Shut-Off for Boiler
elief Valve, at Tra /Water tem 110 De rees Max.
i e roo In Com lete, Penetration Sealed
Furnace In Se arate Room /Protected In Gara e
Li ht Ventilation er Room /Safe Glazin
Attic Access 30" x 20" x 30" H / Crawl S ace 18" x 24"
Final Electrical
Site Plan/Variance Re uired
Final Surve Plot Plan / Flpod Plain Certification, if Re .
As-built Se tic S stem La out Re uired
Buildin / A artment Number on Buildin or Drivewa
Build Access All Sides b 20', Driveable Surface 20" Wide
Oka To Issue Tem C/O or Permanent CO (circle one)
Oka To Issue C/C
C
COMMENTS:
u~aa~, r~rru~.r+iivrva-vrri~,t uat~muuir~t vwt~urvv.aoc
Durham's Bay Resort
2999 State Rt. 9L
Lake George, NY 12845
(518) 656-9242
March 12, 2007
Dave Hatin
Director of Building and Codes
Town of Queensbury
742 Bay Road
Queensbury, NY 12804
Dave,
~~ D~ ~
BUILDING ArJD CC1DE
Please find enclosed building permit application for Durham's Bay Resort. This
application is for the following work.
Conversion of two hotel units into one 1 BR suite. The scope of the project is to remove
approx. 8.5' of existing wall separating the two units and constructing of approx. 25' of
new 2" x 4" wall to create the two bedrooms. We will also be installing a mini kitchen
which will consist of a two burner cooktop and a 24" SS sink installed into two base
cabinets.
I have spoken to Mike Palmer about the fire code issues and he informs me that we are
within code on these items. His only concern was that we add one additions smoke
detector. This will give us a total of three per unit.
Please feel free to contact me with any questions or concerns you may have @
(518) 577-8838.
Sincerely,
~~~
Paul J. Gentner
Facilities Manager
Durham's Bay Resort
New York State Department of Environmental Conservation
Office of Environmental Quality, Region 5
232 Golf Course Road - P. O. Box 220, Warrensburg, New York 12885-0220
Phone: (518) 623-1238 FAX: (518) 623-1311
Website: www.dec.state.ny.us
Alexander B. Grannis
May 2, 2007 Commissioner
Mr. John Salvador, Jr.
37 Alexy Lane
Lake George, NY 12845
Re: Dunham's Bay Lodge
SPDES Permit No. NY-0131601
Queensbury (T), Warrens (Co.)
Dear Mr. Salvador:
This is in response to your letter and our recent telephone conversations regarding the above
referenced facility. Your concern focuses on the proposal before the Town of Queensbury
(Queensbury) to convert the existing motel units which do not have kitchenettes into motel units
with kitchenette facilities. Further, you noted concern with respect to how that proposal would
affect wastewater generation and State Pollutant Discharge Elimination System (SPDES) Permit
No. NY-013161, issued by the New York State Department of Environmental Conservation
(DEC or Department) for the subject facility.
I have reviewed Department files and have also discussed the Dunham's Bay Lodge proposal
with the Queensbury Building and Code Enforcement Office, who provided a copy of the subject
proposed modifications. You are correct that SPDES Permit No. NY-0131601 authorizes a
sanitary discharge to groundwater of 1,920 gallons per day (gpd). You are also correct that the
discharge was based upon six 4-unit motel buildings and a 20 percent flow reduction for the use
of water saving fixtures. DEC Design Standards for Wastewater Treatment Works in the Lake
George Drainage Basin, dated July 1989 (LG Standards), provided guidance on wastewater
generation for system design. As we have discussed, the LG Standards Table 3-B, Expected
Hydraulic Loading Rates, provides for 100 gpd per motel unit without kitchenette and 150 gpd
per motel unit with kitchenette. Both of these loadings may be reduced by twenty percent when
water saving fixtures are used.
Your letter and the information provided by Queensbury agree that the proposal is to convert
two adjacent single bedroom units into a single 2 bedroom unit with kitchenette. Each motel
building may undergo this proposed transformation. I have provided the following table to show
wastewater design flows based upon the relevant information:
Facility Type LG Standards Water Saving .Units per ~ Total Number Total Design
Design Flow Fixture Building of Units Flow
(gpd/unit) Design Flow ~ (6 building) (gpd/unit x #
(gpd/unit) units)
Motel unit 100 80 4 24 1,920
(w/o kitchenette)
Motel unit 150 120 2 12 1,440
with kitchenette
Mr. John Salvador, Jr. May 2, 2007
Re: Dunham's Bay Lodge
SPDES Permit No. NY-0131601
Queensbury (T), Warrens (Co.)
Page 2
You will note that the above table contradicts your claim that the proposed motel changes would
yield a 50 percent increase in wastewater design flow. In fact, based upon the conditions
presented and the LG Standards, the proposed changes would result in an 80 gpd per building
design flow reduction, or, in other terms, a 25 percent reduction in total calculated design flow.
Actual flows will vary, however, a reduction in-flow would remain as the expected result from the
presented proposal.
Your argument that motel units with kitchenettes could potentially be used in a manner of
occupancy less transient in nature, such as a substitute for an apartment or other more
long-term housing, is a matter that you should discuss with Queensbury. Further, questions on
Queensbury's definition of a motel and/or motel unit, as you have quoted to me, and how it
applies to the Dunham's Bay Lodge proposal will also have to be addressed to Queensbury.
Other concerns with the regulation of transient lodging may be addressed with the New York
State Department of Health.
Sincerely, ,~
,~.
,_
Michael A. Dauphinais, Jr.
Environmental Program Specialist 2
Division of Water
MAD:Ic
cc: A. Gabalski - NYSDOH
M. White - LGPC
D. Hatin - (T) Queensbury
Dunham's Bay Lodge
TOWN OF QUEENSBURY
i-~? Bai/ Poa~1, Q~rc'c'ia~br>>';~, N1~". i ?~04-591)7
~~~~~I
May 8, 2007
Paul Gentner
Facilities Manager
Dunham's Bay Resort
2999 State Rte. 9L
Lake George, NY 12845
Re: Proposed improvements
Tax Map No: 252-1-75.4
Dear Mr. Gentner:
I am writing to you in response to your March 6, 2007 letter addressed to Dave Hatin of this
office. I have reviewed your letter along with Building Permit applications 2007-87, 88, 89, 90,
91, 93 and 94.
The property in question is located within a Rural Residential, {RR-3A) zoning district within the
Town of Queensbury. Your current use of the property is classified as a MOTEL per the Town
of Queensbury Zoning Ordinance. A motel use within the RR-3A zoning district is not an
allowable use by right. As such, your current use of the property is considered to be a pre-
existing, non-conforming use.
As I understand your proposal, as outlined in your letter, you wish to convert the 24 cottage units
into 12 cottage units all within the existing 6 buildings located southerly of the main lodge.
Also, I understand your intentions to include the completion of the locker room facilities
adjacent to the indoor pool, the addition of a 1 bedroom suite on the third level and the addition
of a 260 sf walk-in-cooler adjacent to the existing kitchen all of which are located in the main
lodge.
Additionally, based on our previous conversations and my subsequent conversations with Tom
Jarrett, PE of Jarrett/Martin Engineering regarding your project, it is my understanding that your
project may include construction of additional outdoor seating areas and an additional pool
facility. None of these items have been formally presented to this office for a determination;
however, I will offer my position on the same, which may be subject to change pending the
submission of additional detailed information.
As referenced above, the Durham's Bay Resort complex is apre-existing, non-conforming use
within the RR-3A zone. No expansion, enlargement of services or facilities, increase in intensity
of use or facilities may occur without the granting of a Use Variance by the Town of Queensbury
Zoning Board of Appeals. To date, no such approvals have been applied for or granted far your
project.
"H~~ure cif Natural Beant~/,.. ~ Good Plane to Lime"
While the conversion of the 24 seasonal use cottage units to 12 seasonal use cottage units does
not, on the surface, appeaz to represent an expansion, should the conversion of the units include
conversion from seasonal use to year round use, such a change will constitute an increase in the
intensity of the use and be subject to a Use Variance prior to commencement. It is unclear to me,
from the plans that you have submitted, if such a seasonal to year round conversion is planned
for the cottage units. Please provide clarification on this matter so that a final determination can
be made relative to your pending Building Permit applications.
The addition of a 1 bedroom suite (Bridal Suite), a 260 sf walk-in-cooler, a pool facility and
outdoor seating areas constitute an expansion of the use and an enlargement of the facilities and
shall be subject to a Use Variance prior to commencement.
This letter will serve as a written notification of my determination and written notice to STOP
WORK on any areas identified as being subject to a Use Variance if any such work has begun.
I also note, as referenced in your letter, that your proposal includes cosmetic improvements to
the restaurant and kitchen areas for, what I can only assume to be an attempt to make the
restaurant more appealing to the general public in addition to your lodge guests. Please confirm
that your project site can support the pazking requirements for the lodging use along with the
restaurant use in the event that both uses aze operating at full capacity independently of each
other.
Should you have any additional questions or comments please do not hesitate to contact this
office. We await your submittal of the requested information.
Sincerely,
Queensbury
Haig Brown
Zoning Administrator
CB/sh
Cc: Michael Borgos, Esq. (via fax as requested )
L:\Craig Brown\2007 letters\Gentner DB Resort 5 4 07.doc
~' ~~~~
j
~~
Dun~m s Bad Resort
~~ ~~ State Rte, ,~-,~
Lake C,~eor~e, avy ~284s
(5.~8) X56-82,42
May 11, 20Q7
Craig Brown
Zoning Administrator
Town of Queensbury
742 Bay Road
Queensbury, NY u8o4
Dear Mr. Broom,
b _
I have reviewed your letter dated May+ 8,, 2007 and this letter is to inform you than} we
are not chamgin9 the use of the facNity.
We are also reserving our right to p~~ that the cottages are not
seasonal.. and have been used beyond six months pq~ y~
Smcenely,
p~~~~
Paut Genb,er
fadlities Manager